Subscription Boxes for Dog Owners have become an absolute game-changer for pet parents who want to add a dash of joy and surprise to their dog’s life every month. Imagine this: your dog’s eyes lighting up, tail wagging furiously, as you open a box filled with new toys and treats, each one carefully chosen to make their day extra special. For those of us who want to spoil our pets without constantly shopping for the next best thing, these subscription boxes take the guesswork out of choosing high-quality, exciting toys and delicious treats that keep our dogs entertained and happy.
But with so many options out there, how do you know which one is right for your dog? BarkBox and Super Chewer are two of the most popular choices, each offering unique benefits that cater to different kinds of dogs. BarkBox is ideal for playful pups who enjoy themed toys and softer, gentle play, while Super Chewer is built for those strong, determined chewers who need something extra tough to keep them engaged.
In this post, we’ll dive into everything you need to know about these two standout subscription boxes for dogs, comparing their features, durability, and the kind of fun they deliver. By the end, you’ll have a clear picture of which box could be the perfect fit for your furry friend, so you can bring a monthly dose of excitement into their life. Let’s get started!
Table of Contents
Why Choose a Subscription Box for Dogs?
Subscription boxes for dogs are more than just a monthly delivery; they’re a way to keep your dog’s life exciting, happy, and healthier than ever. Here’s why pet owners everywhere are raving about this growing trend.
Convenience: Make Dog Parenting Easier
Let’s face it: life gets busy. Finding the time to hunt down quality dog toys, unique treats, and safe chews can be challenging. Subscription boxes for dogs solve this problem by delivering a carefully curated selection of items directly to your door each month. No more last-minute pet store runs or hours spent scrolling online—these boxes provide exactly what your dog needs, without any of the hassle. It’s the ultimate way to ensure your pup has fresh, safe, and enjoyable goodies on hand without interrupting your schedule.

Variety and Excitement: Keep Your Dog’s Tail Wagging
Dogs thrive on novelty. Seeing new toys and tasting different treats triggers their curiosity, reducing boredom and increasing engagement. With each box, there’s a new theme, which means different textures, shapes, and flavors for your dog to explore. Imagine the joy in their eyes as they sniff out every new item in the box—it’s like their own little holiday every month! This variety is especially valuable for dogs that need mental stimulation or tend to get bored quickly. It’s an easy way to add a little adventure to your dog’s daily routine.
Quality and Value: Get More Bang for Your Buck
One of the best-kept secrets about subscription boxes for dogs is that they’re often more cost-effective than buying individual items separately. These boxes are put together by pet experts who know what’s best for dogs, which means you’re getting high-quality, durable products that are safe and suitable for your pup. Rather than testing out random toys or treats that may not last or appeal to your dog, these boxes deliver tried-and-tested favorites that dogs genuinely love. Plus, with the subscription format, you’re often able to get these premium products at a discount, giving you more value for your money each month.
Subscription boxes bring simplicity, joy, and peace of mind to dog owners, offering a convenient way to show your dog just how much they mean to you. And with options like BarkBox and Super Chewer, there’s a perfect box for every pup, whether they’re a gentle player or a powerful chewer.
BarkBox Overview

BarkBox is a monthly subscription box tailored for playful, average chewers, delivering themed toys, treats, and chews right to your doorstep. Each box is thoughtfully curated with quality products, designed to keep dogs engaged and happy. Here’s a closer look at what BarkBox offers, including an overview of its unique themes, customization options, pricing, and customer feedback.
What is BarkBox?
BarkBox is one of the leading dog subscription boxes, known for its playful and imaginative themes that change every month. From “Jurassic Bark” to “Space Jam,” each box contains toys and treats that align with a creative storyline, making it exciting for both pets and their owners.
What’s Inside Each BarkBox?
- 2 Themed Toys: Each box includes two plush or squeaky toys that fit the monthly theme.
- 2 Bags of Treats: High-quality treats made in the USA or Canada, crafted with dog-safe ingredients.
- 1 Chew: A long-lasting chew, tailored to provide dogs with an additional source of enjoyment.
Customization Options
BarkBox allows for some customization to make sure the contents suit each dog’s preferences:
- Toy Preferences: You can select plush or squeaky toys and specify if your dog has any preferences.
- Allergy-Friendly Treats: BarkBox offers a special box with allergen-friendly treats, removing common allergens like beef, chicken, and turkey.
- Additional Toys: For an extra cost, you can add a third toy to the box each month.
BarkBox Pricing and Subscription Plans
BarkBox’s pricing model offers flexibility, allowing subscribers to save by committing to a longer-term plan.
Subscription Plan | Monthly Price | Total Cost (Paid Upfront) | Cost per Toy/Treat |
---|---|---|---|
1-Month | $35 | $35 | $7 |
6-Month | $26 | $156 | $5.20 |
12-Month | $23 | $276 | $4.60 |
Cost Comparison Chart
Below is a bar chart comparing the average cost per item across different subscription plans:

This chart helps visualize the value that comes with longer-term plans, where subscribers enjoy a lower cost per item.
Customer Feedback and Reviews
BarkBox has received overwhelmingly positive feedback from customers, especially for its attention to quality and creativity in every box. Here are some common highlights:
- Positive Points:
- Themed Toys: Customers appreciate the uniqueness of each theme, as it makes unboxing fun and special.
- Treat Quality: High marks for treats made with natural ingredients and no artificial preservatives.
- Customer Service: BarkBox’s responsive customer service often receives praise for resolving issues quickly and accommodating preferences.
- Areas for Improvement:
- Durability of Toys: Some customers mention that the toys may not hold up for heavy chewers, which is why BarkBox recommends Super Chewer for dogs with stronger chewing habits.
Why Choose BarkBox?
BarkBox is an excellent choice for dog owners who want to add an element of surprise and variety to their dog’s routine. It’s ideal for average chewers who enjoy themed toys, tasty treats, and love to explore new surprises every month. The customization options and allergy-friendly treats make it adaptable to specific needs, providing a thoughtful way to spoil your pet regularly.
Super Chewer Overview

Super Chewer is the tough sibling to BarkBox, designed specifically for dogs who love to chew, tug, and destroy. Built with durability in mind, each box delivers sturdy, high-quality toys and long-lasting treats, ensuring it stands up to even the strongest chewers. Below, we’ll break down what’s inside each Super Chewer box, customization options, pricing, and customer feedback, along with a visual cost comparison chart.
What is Super Chewer?
Super Chewer is ideal for dogs with a strong chewing instinct. Unlike standard subscription boxes, Super Chewer toys are crafted from durable materials like rubber and nylon, making them resistant to aggressive play.
What’s Inside Each Super Chewer Box?
- 2 Durable Toys: Made with tougher materials that can withstand powerful chewers, these toys are designed for strength and longevity.
- 2 Bags of Treats: Sourced and made with dog-safe, high-quality ingredients in the USA or Canada.
- 2 Chews: Meant to satisfy dogs’ natural chewing instincts, these long-lasting chews offer an additional source of fun and engagement.
Customization Options
Super Chewer, like BarkBox, allows some level of customization to make sure each box is suited to your dog’s needs:
- Allergy-Friendly Options: Customers can opt for boxes that exclude common allergens, making it a great choice for sensitive dogs.
- Additional Toys: For an extra charge, Super Chewer offers an option to add a third toy for dogs needing a bit more variety.
Super Chewer Pricing and Subscription Plans
Super Chewer’s pricing, similar to BarkBox, offers discounts for longer-term commitments.
Subscription Plan | Monthly Price | Total Cost (Paid Upfront) | Cost per Toy/Treat |
---|---|---|---|
1-Month | $45 | $45 | $7.50 |
6-Month | $35 | $210 | $5.83 |
12-Month | $30 | $360 | $5.00 |
Cost Comparison Chart
The bar chart below compares the average cost per item across different subscription plans:

This chart visually represents the savings subscribers can enjoy by choosing a longer plan.
Customer Feedback and Reviews
Super Chewer has earned high marks from pet parents of strong chewers, especially for its durable toy materials and high-quality treats.
- Positive Points:
- Toy Durability: Customers frequently praise the quality and resilience of Super Chewer toys, noting they last much longer than standard toys.
- Natural Treats: Dog owners love the wholesome ingredients, as treats are often free from artificial preservatives.
- Variety and Themes: Like BarkBox, Super Chewer boxes come with creative themes, adding an element of fun to the unboxing experience.
- Areas for Improvement:
- Cost: The higher price point may be a drawback for some, though most agree it’s worth the investment for durable toys.
- Preference Customization: While Super Chewer offers allergen-friendly options, some customers request more variety in toy type.
Why Choose Super Chewer?
Super Chewer is perfect for dog owners who need durable, long-lasting toys and high-quality treats for their powerful chewers. It’s the ideal choice for dogs who often tear through regular toys and need something more substantial. With options for customization and tough toys, Super Chewer delivers a high-value experience that caters to dogs with serious play and chew instincts.
Key Differences Between BarkBox and Super Chewer
When it comes to choosing the right subscription box for your dog, BarkBox and Super Chewer cater to different types of play styles and chewing needs. Both bring joy, excitement, and high-quality items to your pup’s life, but they do it in ways that match specific dog personalities. Here’s how they differ, so you can find the perfect match for your furry friend.
Feature | BarkBox | Super Chewer |
---|---|---|
Toy Durability | Average Chewers | Heavy Chewers |
Monthly Theme | Fun & Plush | Durable & Themed |
Ideal Dog Type | Gentle Players | Strong Chewers |
Cost-Effectiveness | More Affordable | Pricier but Durable |
1. Durability of Toys

- BarkBox: Ideal for average chewers who enjoy plush, squeaky toys and gentle play. The toys are creative, fun, and come with soft textures that most dogs find irresistible.
- Super Chewer: Made for heavy-duty chewers who need tougher toys. Built from durable materials like rubber and nylon, Super Chewer toys are designed to withstand intense play, making them perfect for dogs that love to chew and tug.
2. Themed Experience
- BarkBox: Each box offers a fully immersive theme, from “Space Jam” to “Jurassic Bark.” It’s a treat for both dogs and their owners to unbox these charming themes, each with plush toys, treats, and chews to match.
- Super Chewer: Super Chewer also offers themes, but the toys are designed to be more functional and long-lasting. The themes are less about plush fun and more about engaging, durable play.
3. Cost-Effectiveness

- BarkBox: A great choice if you want quality toys and treats for a lower monthly cost. It’s cost-effective for dogs who enjoy variety but don’t need ultra-tough toys.
- Super Chewer: Although it’s a bit pricier, it’s worth the investment for dogs that would otherwise go through several toys a month. The higher price reflects the materials and durability, saving owners money in the long run for strong chewers.
4. Ideal Dog Match

- BarkBox: Best for dogs who enjoy gentle play, plush textures, and discovering new themes. Perfect for dogs who love variety but aren’t likely to destroy their toys.
- Super Chewer: Best for strong, determined chewers who need heavy-duty toys. It’s an ideal choice for breeds like Labradors, German Shepherds, and other large dogs with strong chewing habits.
Pros and Cons of BarkBox and Super Chewer
When choosing between BarkBox and Super Chewer, it helps to weigh the advantages and limitations of each option. Here’s a breakdown to help you make the best choice for your pup!
BarkBox: Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Fun Themed Toys: Each month’s box is thoughtfully curated around a unique theme, adding a surprise element that both dogs and owners enjoy.
- Variety of Toys and Treats: BarkBox includes two toys, two treat bags, and a chew in every box, providing a good mix of options for different play styles and preferences.
- Affordability: BarkBox is budget-friendly, especially with the cost savings in longer subscription plans.
- Customizable for Allergies: Options for allergen-friendly treats make it suitable for dogs with specific dietary needs.
Cons:
- Not Suitable for Heavy Chewers: While the toys are high-quality, they are best suited for average chewers. Dogs with strong chewing instincts may go through the toys faster.
- Limited Durability: Plush toys and softer textures mean that some toys might not last long for dogs that prefer tougher play.
Super Chewer: Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Durable Toys for Strong Chewers: Designed with tough materials like rubber and nylon, Super Chewer toys withstand rough play, making them ideal for dogs that enjoy chewing and tugging.
- High-Quality Treats: The treats are made in the USA or Canada with natural, dog-safe ingredients, ensuring quality with every bite.
- Fun Yet Functional Themes: Although durable, Super Chewer boxes still come with fun themes, making each unboxing an enjoyable experience.
- Customizable for Allergies: Super Chewer also offers allergen-free options for dogs with dietary sensitivities.
Cons:
- Higher Price Point: Super Chewer costs more per box, but the value comes from the durability of the toys. This might not be as cost-effective for owners of gentler chewers.
- Limited Soft Toy Options: Super Chewer primarily focuses on durable toys, so it may not be ideal for dogs that prefer plush, soft toys.
BarkBox and Super Chewer each offer distinct benefits, catering to different dog personalities and chewing styles. Whether you’re looking for playful themes or indestructible toys, one of these boxes is bound to bring joy to your dog’s routine!
Which Box is Best for Your Dog?
Choosing the right box depends on your dog’s personality and play style:

- If your dog loves variety, playful themes, and plush toys, then BarkBox is the perfect fit. It’s ideal for dogs who are gentle players and enjoy exploring new treats and fun surprises.
- If your dog is a strong chewer with a taste for durability, Super Chewer is designed to handle tough play. This box is the best choice for dogs that need more resilient toys and enjoy a good challenge with their treats.
Both boxes bring unique excitement to your dog’s life—choose the one that matches your pup’s play habits for endless fun each month!
How to Get Started
Ready to treat your dog to a monthly surprise of toys, treats, and chews? Whether they’re a gentle player who loves themed plush toys or a strong chewer that needs durable fun, both BarkBox and Super Chewer offer something special for every pup.
Sign up today to bring endless joy and excitement to your dog’s routine. Click the links below to get started, and make your dog’s month with BarkBox or Super Chewer!
FAQ Section

Q1: Can I switch between BarkBox and Super Chewer?
Yes! If you find that one box isn’t quite the right fit, you can easily switch between BarkBox and Super Chewer. Simply log into your account or reach out to customer service for assistance.
Q2: What if my dog has allergies?
Both BarkBox and Super Chewer offer options to accommodate common dog allergies. You can request a box without certain ingredients, such as chicken, beef, or turkey, making it safe for dogs with dietary sensitivities.
Q3: Can I cancel my subscription at any time?
Yes, both BarkBox and Super Chewer offer flexible subscriptions. You can cancel at any time through your account settings, but be sure to check if you’re on a prepaid plan to understand any refund policies.
Q4: Are there promotions for first-time subscribers?
Yes, BarkBox and Super Chewer often offer discounts or special gifts for new subscribers. Check the current promotions on their websites for any deals when you sign up!
Conclusion
BarkBox and Super Chewer each bring unique joy to a dog’s life, catering to different personalities and play styles. BarkBox is perfect for dogs who love a mix of fun and surprises, while Super Chewer is a great fit for those needing extra durability and long-lasting engagement. No matter your choice, each box delivers high-quality treats and toys that enrich your dog’s routine and bring excitement to their month.

Treat your furry friend to a subscription today and watch their tail wag with joy each time a new box arrives!